An ongoing, real-time discussion for cool English Dork Seniors engaged in exploring big questions, ideas, and texts.
Monday, November 11, 2013
Indian Education?
This story is told in first person by Victor and is mostly about Victor's life growing up, but includes various less important characters throughout. Although in the previous stories we've read, we see Victor growing up as he started off as a young boy in Every Little Hurricane and from there aged, in this story we get a recap of all of his younger years from an unknown later perspective. He begins as a warrior, but slowly but surely realizes his inevitable future. He not only begins to lose his innocence but losing a connection with his people after kissing the white girl. This story shows more racism and more stereotypes that people put upon Indians such as the assumption that him passing out due to diabetes was him being drunk, or that the white father beating his white daughter must have been Indian. As Victor graduates, keeps a straight face as he thinks about the future. In this moment, I saw this as a little bit of his warrior still being there was he graduated on top of his class. His friends however, graduating with smiles on their faces think about the partying they will take part in. Years later, Victor looks back and wonders what it was all for. While he got pushed around and grew strong, his friends were together and never thought there was anything they could do after high school besides drink and party. He is faced with the truth that although he received an education, in the end he has the same future as the rest of the people on the reservation.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Very interesting viewpoint. I found it really interesting how he seems to be caught in two worlds: with the Indians at the reservation and with the whites at the farm school. As you the mention, it is interesting how he notes: "I try to remain stoic for the photographers as I look toward the future" (179). However, the difference is even crazier as Victor points out: "My graduating class has a reunion every weekend at the Powwow Tavern" (180). Once again, Alexie has a really sad tone here; the dreams and aspirations between the two worlds are completely different. I felt that Alexie was trying very hard to make a connection between the two worlds when writing this short story but had difficulty finding the common denominator.
ReplyDeleteIndian Education is actually a true story. At least the high school part is. True in the sense that it was drawn from Alexie's own experiences
ReplyDeleteI thought this story was from the perspective of Junior Polatkin....
ReplyDeleteYeah I know. Junior Polatkin is a great basketball player at a "farm town high school" nicknamed the "Indians" and he is the only Indian kid at the school, and he is the valedictorian and all of that. Sherman Alexie also went to an all white high school whose nickname was the "Indians" at which he was a star basketball player and a great student. I guess I worded it wrong by saying it was "true".
ReplyDeleteyikes yeah sorry guys, I misunderstood and thought it was told by victor
ReplyDeleteYea I think that he might be changed when he's telling the stories because he is reminiscent of the times he tell us about especially the basketball story and I feel like he probably fell into some sort of problem with his life. It might not be alcoholism but it could just be something like losing his wife that makes him so nostalgic over the past.
ReplyDelete